The Best Wood Species for Log Homes (Ranked & Reviewed)

Choosing the wood species for your log home is the single most expensive decision you will make. It dictates your budget, your insulation value (R-value), and—most importantly—your maintenance schedule for the next 30 years.

Many homeowners assume that "wood is wood." This is a costly mistake.

• Pine shrinks significantly.

• Cedar naturally repels bugs but costs a premium.

• Spruce is affordable but prone to rot.

There is no "perfect" wood, but there is a perfect maintenance plan for each one. Below, we rank the top 5 wood species used in North America and prescribe the exact Weatherall protection system required to keep them standing strong.

1. Western Red Cedar (The Gold Standard)

Best For: Longevity and harsh climates.

Western Red Cedar is widely considered the premium choice for log homes. It naturally produces toxic oils (thujaplicins) that make the wood resistant to decay, termites, and carpenter bees. It also has a low moisture content, meaning your home won't "settle" or twist as aggressively as Pine.

• Pros: High R-value (insulator), natural insect defense, minimal warping.

• Cons: High cost. The natural oils can sometimes make it difficult for standard stains to adhere.

The Weatherall Protocol for Cedar

Because Cedar is an "oily" wood, film-forming stains can sometimes peel if the wood isn't prepped perfectly.

• The Stain: We recommend SuSTAIN Exterior Wood Finish. This is a semi-transparent, deep-penetrating oil-based stain. It works with the cedar's natural oils rather than fighting them, diving into the wood grain for maximum adhesion.

• The Prep: New Cedar can suffer from "mill glaze." Always wash the logs with a TSP/Bleach solution or perform a light sanding to open the pores before staining.

2. Eastern White Pine (The Value King)

Best For: Budgets and availability.

Pine is the most common log home wood in the United States. It is affordable, beautiful, and easy to find. However, Pine is a "softwood" with low natural resistance to rot. It also has high water content when green, leading to significant shrinking and settling (up to 2-3 inches per wall) as it dries.

• Pros: Affordable, light golden color, easy to source.

• Cons: High shrinkage, prone to "Blue Stain" fungus, zero natural insect resistance.

The Weatherall Protocol for Pine

You cannot leave Pine unprotected for even a single season.

• The Pre-Treatment: You must apply Tim-bor Professional immediately after the shell is up. This borate salt treatment makes the tasty pine wood indigestible to termites and fungi.

• The Chinking: Because Pine moves so much, rigid mortar will crack. You need Triple Stretch Chinking, which acts like a rubber band, stretching and compressing with the logs to keep the seal tight.

3. Spruce (The Kit Favorite)

Best For: Uniform look and pre-fabricated kits.

Engelmann or Sitka Spruce is commonly found in log home kits because it grows straight and is lighter in weight for transport. It is creamy white and takes stain color very evenly. However, it has very low decay resistance compared to Cedar or Cypress.

• Pros: Consistent light color, straight grain, economical.

• Cons: Rot-prone if exposed to ground moisture, sensitive to UV damage.

The Weatherall Protocol for Spruce

Spruce is like a sponge—it absorbs water easily.

• The Protection: You need a high-performance film-forming finish. UV Guard II provides a "shield" over the soft spruce wood, blocking UV rays and shedding rainfall.

• The Foundation: Never allow Spruce logs to touch the ground. Ensure you have a high stone or concrete foundation, and seal the bottom log heavily with Epoxy Wood Hardener if you spot any soft areas.

4. Cypress (The Southern Fortress)

Best For: Humid, swampy climates.

Often called "The Wood Eternal," Cypress generates a natural preservative oil called cypressene that makes it biologically engineered to resist rot and moisture. It is heavy, hard, and checks (cracks) less than Pine.

• Pros: Incredible rot resistance, beautiful grain, repels insects.

• Cons: Expensive, takes a long time to dry, primarily available in the Southeast.

The Weatherall Protocol for Cypress

Cypress is dense and holds moisture deep in the center.

• The Stain: Like Cedar, Cypress benefits from the penetrating power of SuSTAIN.

• The Warning: Ensure your moisture readings are below 18% before staining. If you seal moisture inside Cypress with a topcoat too early, it can rot from the inside out.

5. Douglas Fir (The Structural Beast)

Best For: Timber frame beams and trusses.

Douglas Fir is incredibly strong. It is often used for rafters, trusses, and structural beams rather than full wall logs. It has a distinctive reddish hue and a straight grain.

• Pros: Highest structural strength, straight grain.

• Cons: Susceptible to beetle attacks.

The Weatherall Protocol for Douglas Fir

Beetles love the sapwood of Douglas Fir.

• The Additive: Add NBS 30 Insect Repellent to your final coat of stain. This botanical additive masks the wood scent, stopping beetles from boring into your structural beams.

Summary Comparison Table

Frequently Asked Questions

What about Oak or Hardwoods?

Oak and Poplar are beautiful but are rarely used for full log walls because they are incredibly heavy and difficult to insulate (low R-value). They are best reserved for interior accents, stairs, or mantels.

Does Cedar need to be stained?

Yes. While Cedar won't rot immediately, UV rays will turn it gray and damage the wood fibers within 6 months. A penetrating stain like SuSTAIN protects the color and blocks UV damage without peeling.

Why is my Pine log home settling?

Pine has high water content. As it acclimates to your climate, water leaves the cells and the wood shrinks. This is normal. It is why we recommend Triple Stretch Chinking, which stretches to maintain the seal even as the wall moves.

Have you chosen your wood?

Now choose your shield.

No matter which species you build with, Weatherall has a specialized system to protect it.

Shop Stains & Finishes ➝